Carols For Christmas – Two Albums That Have More In Common Than You Might Think


Each year about this time I have found myself sharing a bit of holiday music that has caught my fancy.  You all know that I tend towards the traditional in my Christmas (and Advent) music, but this year I have decided to add something that might appeal to the more jazz-minded among you.  As for the other 92% of you?  Sorry, I’m afraid you are out of luck.  But I think you will find something of interest in at least one of these two selections.  You may also be a little surprised at what these two albums have in common.


First let’s go with the traditional.  A couple of years ago I shared a then-new release from the Benedictine Sisters of Mary, Queen of Apostles.  This community of Benedictine Sisters in northwestern Missouri has been blessed with a number of enthusiastic young sisters who follow the traditional Rule of St. Benedict, the distilled summary of which is “pray and work.”   I ordered their Advent CD (yes, I cannot give up the idea that to “own” some music I have to be able to hold it).  I liked it so well that I bought their first Christmas CD, their inaugural effort from 2008.

Then last year I stumbled across a release by the Dominican House of Studies for the Eastern Province of the U.S., called Christ Was Born To Save.   This collection of all male voices provides a different flavor from that of the Sisters.  They are similar in style but each is unique in its sound.  If you missed either of these pieces, I have linked to them in the bold print just above.

With Christmas approaching once again, I wondered what else along these lines I might be able to find.  I decided to look into what the Benedictine Sisters might have been up to since I last looked and was rewarded with another new release: Caroling at Ephesis.  Which I promptly ordered from their website.  (It is also available from Amazon or  iTunes.)

After enjoying their earlier works, I have enjoyed their newest release no less.  In fact, one less inclined to traditional music might prefer this effort overall due to it being all carols.  While I enjoy some of the Gregorian chant pieces that were found on the other CDs, I could see where they can be “mood killers” when someone is in a “joyous Christmas music” kind of mood.


A video with a sample from the new release can be seen here.


I normally try to find a video sample in a form that can be clicked upon directly, but this one seems to be available only on the Sisters’ website.  But you need to click on the link right before this paragraph.  I’ll wait.  After all, Who doesn’t love the Carol Of The Bells?  Which happens to be Ukranian – something I did not know at all.

Some of the carols are familar while many are not (or at least were not to me).  But after a couple of times through I have found each of them a worthwhile addition to my seasonal soundtrack.  Most all of these gems were mined from the deep caroling traditions of England, France, Germany and elsewhere in both western and eastern Europe.  Don’t tell me that Western Civilization didn’t produce something worthwhile.

Why does this music appeal to me so?  I am a sucker for beauty and these Sisters can make some beautiful music, let me tell you.  I love the way that their voices mix in the complex chords that their skill level permits them to carry off so well.

I also love seeing (and listening to) young people who consider their faith so important that they are willing to give up so much in order to make it their life work.  Christmas seems a little more real to me when women like these are singing the songs that make the season special.


OK, now for a change of pace.  This next recommendation is neither new nor strictly traditional.  It is also not strictly jazz.  If you are already familar with A Merry Christmas by Stan Kenton, you can just nod your head as I explain why the rest of you should listen to it.  Several months back I featured a Stan Kenton record from the mid 1970s in one of my meanderings into jazz.  That record was Kenton at the end of his life – still interesting but definitely on the downhill side of his career.  A Merry Christmas is a product of the final peak period of Stan the Man’s creativity.



Frankly, I wasn’t sure what I would be getting when I ordered this one online a few years ago during a deep dive into the Kenton catalog.  Stan Kenton’s records were always kind of like Forrest Gump’s box of chocolates – you never knew what you were going to get.  This was not only because his quality could be a little uneven, but mainly because he went through musical styles like most of us go through clean dishes.  This Christmas album from 1961 turned out to be quite unlike anything else I had heard from his band.

Stan Kenton leading a nineteen piece band was nothing unusual.  A nineteen piece band made up entirely of brass and percussion/rhythm instruments was definitely unusual, even by Kenton standards.  For those who don’t normally follow these things, nineteen pieces is on the large size of bands that include a full five piece reed/saxophone section.  But there are no saxophones here.

Here is one sample – We Three Kings.  I chose this one to share specifically because in a little over two minutes it goes from full traditional to full jazz and back again without even a little bit of awkwardness in the transition.  All of the Kenton hallmarks are there: the prominent low brass (tuba and trombones), the intricate arrangements and the clean, crisp trumpet section that lives live way, way up there in the horns’ range.


One other thing you may notice right away is the four man mellophonium section.  This was an instrument that was the product of a collaboration between Kenton and the C. G. Conn Company (of Elkhart, Indiana, by the way), the manufacturer.  It is a cross between a trumpet (it plays in a high range) and a french horn (which has a very fluid, mellow tone).  They were notoriously difficult to keep in tune.  Also they were played by guys who normally played trumpet and who actively hated the things.  Kenton’s bands of the early ’60s have come to be called his Mellophonium Bands and this was one of the records made in that short but excellent era.

Here is another thing that sticks out:  Most jazz or jazz-like collections of Christmas music are heavy on Santa, snow and the romantic roasting of chestnuts.  There is none of that here.  Kenton agreed to do the album on one condition – that he would get to do traditional carols, but do them his way.  His way was . . . really good.

Stan Kenton played music like nobody else and these carols are like nothing else I have heard.  Can music be both traditional and midcentury modern?  Both not-jazz and jazz all at the same time?  This album proves that it can, indeed, be done.  And here it is done very, very well.


I recently had a conversation with one of my sons and a brother in law.  Each of them tried to convince me that the canon of decent Christmas music did not slam closed with the dawning of the rock era.  They argued their point well, citing Mariah Carey’s All I Want For Christmas Is You as a modern Christmas song that has stood the test of time.

Well, I’m not buying.  I am not a hater of a more secular style of Christmas music, so long as it is good music.  And I will admit that my specs may be a little tighter here than would be the case for most of the rest of you.  Bing and Nat and Frank are all part of my holiday playlist.

But I have a longstanding love for genuine Christmas carols.  Really folks – these need to be sung and listened to.  Civilization doesn’t just pass itself along to the next generation by itself.  It is up to us to keep traditional carols from falling (farther) into obscurity.   And as long as there is a deep well of real carols to be played, whether in an overtly religious rendition by some Benedictine Sisters or in the inimitable style of Stan Kenton, my celebration of Christmas will be everything it should be.  And I hope that yours will be as well.

17 thoughts on “Carols For Christmas – Two Albums That Have More In Common Than You Might Think

  1. The Benedictine sisters caroling those bells were lovely. BTW, that video is actually hosted on Vimeo. Put this URL on a line by itself in your post and it should pop right up:


    • Thanks for the technical support. I will look into this after a bit.
      They really are lovely. I have had this playing at every opportunity since I got it. What a great soundtrack to get stuck in my head.


  2. I still love the Charlie Brown Christmas music – to the point where I bought the CD a few years ago, and played it regularly throughout December. Unfortunately, the new Honda does not have a CD player. Interesting that you bring up the Mariah Carey song. The other day my six-year-old asked me to turn the satellite radio to the “Holly” channel. She wanted to hear that particular song! She has asked to hear that song regularly.


    • Charlie Brown is a favorite of mine too. Both of my daily cars still have CD players and Aux input jacks – the best of all worlds.
      Those “All Christmas Music” channels on the radio – I just can’t.


  3. I WISH TO RENOUNCE MY LIFE AND JOIN THE ORDER OF THE BENEDICTINES OF MARY, QUEEN OF ANGELS. (But only if my husband can come along too. 🙂 All joking aside, JP, thank you for sharing these absolute treasures!


    • Hahaha, I’ve had days where I would too, but I don’t think I would make it beyond the storm door.
      It was funny, my Mrs and I went to a Christmas concert at another church. The performed two selections I knew (and love) from the Benedictine Sisters CDs I have. I felt like such an authority on obscure carols. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      • Neat article. Those Dominican sisters in Ann Arbor are a different group that also have a new Christmas CD out. Maybe that will be my purchase for next year.
        For the first 6 months or so after my son expressed an interest in the Dominicans, I constantly mixed them up with the Benedictines, an even older group founded by St. Benedict in 529 AD. Benedict, Dominic, who can keep this stuff straight, right? It ain’t easy. 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

      • Oh, goodness … how silly of me, JP. Clearly I’ve lost all reason (or ability to read) on account of my nun-craziness. Thank you for setting the record straight. Or the CD, as the case may be. 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

  4. How’d I miss this on Friday? I think I was organizing a spare parts list for an HPU, oh boy.

    Anyway Kenton sounds a little busy for first thing Sunday morning, but I’ll have to tell my trumpet playing kid about the mellophonium.

    Benedictine Sisters are more like it 🙂

    My son and I are playing the “Blue Christmas” service tonight. Initially I though I’d get to dress like Elvis, but it’s a simple and somber service for people who have suffered loss this year. Just guitar and bass this year too, I won’t be feeling that somber since it’s a blast to make music with your kid..


  5. Love We Three Kings! My daughters choir did a version of Carol of the Bells this year that took my breath away. My father in law has a Christmas cd (Blues) and at least once every year at the mall I hear one of his songs come on. ;). Merry Christmas JP!


  6. This makes you 2 for 2 on Kenton recommendations. I haven’t listened to all the tracks yet, but I like what I’ve heard so far. Probably a tossup between We 3 Kings, and God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen as to my favorite.

    I enjoy a lot of the more modern Christmas songs, but would admit that most of them are more enjoyable novelties rather than new classics, but going to have to agree with them about Mariah Carey. How about Feliz Navidad? It is newer than I am, but old enough that I don’t remember it being new.


    • Feliz Navidad never really did it for me either, but I don’t hate it. Which is at least some kind of endorsement. 🙂
      The only problem with the Kenton CD is that modern tendency to add “bonus tracks”. There is a spoken word single about Santa Claus and some things from Maynard Ferguson’s band of the late 50s (Ferguson was a Kenton alum known for his incredible range on trumpet). Those additions are not bad things but they are so unlike everything on the original vinyl LP.


      • One of the advantages of modern technology (which I suppose is about a decade out of date now 😉 )
        If I buy a CD, I rip it to the computer, and listen a few times through. The things I like go into a playlist, and the others are easily ignored. 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

  7. Pingback: Baby It’s Bad Outside | J. P.'s Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s