I Wonder – Pvt. Cecil Gant – The (Re-) Birth Of The Blues?

Cecil Gant Wiki

Most recorded music is of its time.  Pick a year and any music lover will conjur a mental soundtrack.  If we were to pick 1944, most people would think of pop tunes like The Andrews Sisters’ Shoo-Shoo Baby or Mairsey Doates by the Merrimacs or maybe the crooning of Frank Sinatra or Bing Crosby.  If we stick to jazz, the players who might pop into our heads are The (Nat) King Cole Trio, Louis Jordan, Coleman Hawkins or Stan Kenton – all of whom were pushing jazz in new directions at that time.

But sometimes we hear a record and realize that it is not at all “of its time”.  We may come back to some examples of things whose time is long past (though not likely soon), but for today let’s look at something that was way out in advance of things to come.

Pvt. Cecil Gant is as enigmatic a figure in music as we are likely to find.  After some time spent in Cleveland as a boy, he returned to his native Tennessee playing and even leading a local band before joining the Army during WWII.  He somehow found himself playing at a War Bond rally in Los Angeles in 1944 and made an impression there for his abilities on the piano.

Cecil Gant Bronze

This local notariety led him, in June of 1944, to a teeny little black-owned record company (The Bronze Record And Recording Company) a few blocks from LA’s Venice Beach where he recorded what might be the most unusual record of 1944 – I Wonder.  The record picked up some steam locally which led him about 15 miles inland to the slightly less-teeny Gilt-Edge Records where he re-recorded it for national distribution.

Actually, according to some comments on 45World.com’s page devoted to this record, it may actually have been recorded in the garage of producer Cliff McDonald who sold it to Gilt-Edge.  With the record being given the number of Gilt-Edge 500 CG1, this might have been the first disc that Gilt-Edge released.

Cecil Gant I Wonder

Whereupon it jumped to No. 1 on the Billboard Harlem Hit Parade (the precursor to Billboard’s R&B chart) and even made a respectable showing on the pop charts as a whole.

This effort was a genuine one-man show with Gant having written the music and lyrics, and also playing the (slightly out-of-tune) piano as he sang.  Gant put out a number of other records which were either soulful ballads like this or up-tempo boogie-woogie piano pieces that were much more in tune with current styles.  His popularity seemed to ebb a bit with each new release until his untimely death in 1951.

There are a couple of sources where I get regular exposure to new-old jazz and hats off here to the 78Prof who blew me away with this one.

What is so unusual about it?  Take a listen and you will hear it.  First, note the complete absense of any kind of swing rhythm.  This could have just as easily come from 1954 or 1964.  The chord progressions and the almost gospel flavor make this unlike anything being done at that time, something truly new.

Cecil Gant Glt Edge Trade publication 2

A brief review in Billboard magazine (January 6, 1945 at p. 69) was singularly unimpressed with the disc’s sound quality (“sounds more like something picked up with a machine hidden under a table in a smoky back room.”) and not bowled over with Gant’s singing (which was described as “groaning”).  The reviewer was, however, impressed with the song itself which had by then spent weeks on the magazine’s charts.

According to Larry Birnbaum in his 2013 book on the pre-history of rock & roll, music writer Arnold Shaw (who spent over fifty years chronicling jazz) identified this record as the one that “ignited the postwar blues explosion”.

Cecil Gant Mail Sleeve

For myself, I was not looking forward to much when I hit “play” for the first time on this one, but by the time it was over I was compelled to hit that “play” button again and again.  I have never been much of a postwar blues guy (or a prewar blues guy, for that matter) but this record has a haunting, melancholy quality to it that separates it from the time and place and circumstances of its making and ever so clearly influenced scores of musicians who would usher in the sounds that would replace those that everyone was listening to in 1944.

Cecil Gant New Orleans 2

This little quotation from Nick Tosches’ Unsung History of Rock and Roll (found via Wikipedia) was too good to leave out.  Jim Bulleit, co-founder of Bullit Records which recorded Gant later in the 40’s, said of him:

“He drank too much… He would say, “I want to do a session” when he ran out of money. We would get a bass player and a guitarist and get him a piano, and I’d go sit in the control room, and he’d tinkle around on it, and then he’d say “I’m ready,” and tap that bottle; and if we didn’t get it the first time, we didn’t get it, ’cause he couldn’t remember what he did. He’d dream up and write a song while he sat there, and he’d give me the title of it. And the uniqueness of the thing is that all of them sold.”

As noted earlier, Gant died in 1951, apparently of a heart attack, possibly brought on by years of heavy drinking.  It is funny how one can go from being a household name (at least in some circles) with some top-selling records to his credit to being a guy virtually wiped from our collective memories.  By all accounts, he is by now well along in a terminal slide down the memory hole, at least as far as most of us are concerned.  But this fascinating recording and its unique place in history seemed like a good excuse to extend a hand and arrest that slide, if only for about three minutes.


Music Credit:

Gilt-Edge 1944 recording of I Wonder by Pvt. Cecil Gant from the youTube page of the78Prof.

Image Credits:

Undated publicity photo from Wikipedia

Both Bronze and Gilt-Edge record labels – from RateYourMusic.com

1945 Trade advertisement from Gilt-Edge Records from 45worlds.com

Rare mailing sleeve from Gilt-Edge Records – for sale at Popsike.com

Ad for an undated show, possibly in New Orleans – on pinterest

11 thoughts on “I Wonder – Pvt. Cecil Gant – The (Re-) Birth Of The Blues?

  1. Well, there’s another one I never heard of. Again.
    It sounds timeless to me, in the way that I couldn’t place it in time. The production sounds like the 20s or 30s, but no bounce, it’s from the 40’s but no swing.

    Interestingly in 2020 623 N Vernon is a residence (who wouldn’t want to live that close to Venice beach?) and 500 N. Western Avenue is a Buddhist temple.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes, I love those old record labels that put their full street address on them. I even came across an early Buck Owens record from the 50s where the company’s telephone number was on the label. Do you suppose they figured that some wannabe would buy it, play it, then call the number and say “Hey, I can do this too!”?

      That Bronze label disappeared around 1945, and it would not be surprising that it might be in a house. I read somewhere that shellac needed to make records was rationed during the war and the little teeny companies probably couldn’t handle anything that required anything approaching serious production.

      It sounded to me like it could have been behind a montage in a black and white film from the early 60s where the lonely star walks the streets on a rainy night while looking for a friendly face.


  2. Your spotlight on Cecil Grant showed how appreciative you were of his talents, especially after your initial listen. What a shame that so many great singers succumb as a result of heavy drinking … thinking Hank Williams Sr. who comes to mind here. A lonely life on the road and eating/drinking long after the performance that night ends – it is often plane crashes too and those famous singers are too many to mention. P.S. – I didn’t know how to spell “Mairsey Doates” and going over to YouTube to hear it … I recall my mom singing that when I was a kid. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

      • Yes, that’s sad and I wonder if it is still the norm. We are, for the most part, a more health-conscious society after all. I don’t follow any new bands or singers anymore. In fact, I often listen to “oldies” stations and find those songs too loud or repetitive … a sign of old(er) age I guess. 🙂 I went to YouTube to give it a listen, knew the words as you would too. I love to hear the sound from records you showcase or something like Mairsey Doats where you hear the stylus drop, wait a few seconds, then the crackling a little on the grooves. The record player and records (33s or 45s) were a big part of growing up. I don’t own an iPod and still have my Sony Walkman. I listen to music on YouTube if I want to hear an old song and recently I began an Amazon Prime member and they have free music, including whole, uninterrupted albums, so I am once again enjoying some of the lighter songs I enjoyed back in the day.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. The voice is completely different, but the piano playing and the general style reminds me a little of Allen Toussaint, so definitely Blues or at least Blues-adjacent.

    Liked by 1 person

      • The song I’m specifically thinking of is called What do you want the girl to do. There’s a live version on YouTube that is just him and the piano.

        Liked by 1 person

      • I knew more about him than I thought I did, as I looked into him. His songs were splashed across the hit records of many others. I will check that one out.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s