The Piano Recital


I have written before about my complicated history with pianos.  I waxed nostalgic when it was time to find new homes for both My Mother’s Piano and for my own antique upright. There are reasons, however, why that nostalgia took longer to develop than perhaps it should have.

For two years I took piano lessons.  My teacher, Miss Goette, was a friend of my mother.  Miss Goette owned a small home in which the living room doubled as her studio.  It is perhaps the only living room I ever encountered with two baby grand pianos parked side by side, occupying perhaps forty percent of the small room’s floor area.

Every week there was a routine.  My mother would drive me to Miss Goette’s home.  We would open the back door and walk down to the partially finished basement which she had set up as a waiting room, complete with old magazines and uncomfortable chairs.

I would soon hear footsteps from the floor above and voices as the student before me called to another waiting parent.  That meant that it was time to trudge up the stairs for the moment of truth.  Or perhaps the half-hour of truth.

Each thirty minute lesson would begin with my playing what had been assigned the previous week.  In theory, my daily practice sessions (also thirty minutes) were enough to conquer the unfriendly markings on the pages of my piano book.  Then there were also the weeks where I had been successful in sneaking undetected into the kitchen to move the oven timer ahead by five or seven minutes.  With some added delays between pieces or a not-strictly-needed bathroom break, I could get those practices down to maybe fifteen minutes on a good day.

But shortened practice times always showed up early in the weekly lesson.  In my defense, I was not a terribly gifted player.  Sight reading of music was my kryptonite, something I was never able to really master.  But I compensated by engaging in hand-to-hand combat with each measure, one at a time, until I could declare victory.  My way of learning resulted in having essentially memorized the piece.  At that point the music served the same purpose as note cards during a speech.  I didn’t really need it, but it was there just to keep me moving along.

As is the custom with piano teachers, Miss Goette would preside over an annual recital.  The Big Event would take place at the conclusion of the lesson-year (we got summers off) in a local piano store.  Families of all of the students would fill the folding chairs as each kid showed off his or her musical genius.  From kids much younger than me to high schoolers who were quite accomplished, the variety was wide.

I would be given an opportunity to choose from a few pieces of sheet music.  Miss Goetty would play part way through each one so that I could make an informed selection.  I don’t recall what I did the first year, but the second year I was excited about an old piece called Drum Boogie.

Boogie woogie was a 1940s fad that turned out to be one of the segues into rock and roll.  Eight beats to a measure (“eight to the bar” as it was sometimes called) gave off a unique feel and I liked it.  This piano solo was published about a decade after boogie woogie had ceased being a thing, but that caused me no problems.  Drum Boogie it would be.

Each week I practiced Drum Boogie.  The deal was that a recital piece had to be played completely by memory with no sheet music allowed.  Week by week I fought my way through that sheet music until I finally got it under control.  Really, the feeling was like standing atop Mt. Everest and jamming a flagpole into the snow.  I was ready.  Because I completely owned Drum Boogie.

The evening of the recital I was nervous but confident.  This was maybe 1971 and I was ready with my sport coat, tie and carefully combed hair.  My mother and little sister were there, my grandma had driven into town and my father came straight from work.  They would be rewarded with Drum Boogie played to perfection.

At last, the younger kids were finished and I was called to the bench.  I surveyed the unfamiliar keyboard and located my fingers appropriately.  After a deep breath I was ready and ripped into Drum Boogie with great enthusiasm.  I began to relax because I was killing it.   I nailed the opening part and got even better as I moved to the middle section of the piece.  I was ready for the home stretch, the last part of the song that would bring the whole performance home.

I played the last few seconds of the transition and . . . nothing.  I.  Mean.  Nothing.  My mind had suffered a complete and total extinction event.  It was “blue screen” of the brain.  My fingers eagerly awaited instructions, but none came.  There was simply nothing there.

It is amazing how long ten seconds can seem when you are an eleven year old kid sitting in front of a room full of people who are waiting for you to play something.  I thought to myself “For the love of God, what is the matter with you?  You know this cold.”  I hit upon The Solution.  All I had to do was to go back and play that middle part again.  Muscle memory would take over and by the time I got finished this little hiccup would surely be forgotten.  I actually knew better, chose to shrug off that little bit of reality.

So back I went.  My playing may have started off a little less relaxed this time through but I was soon right back in the zone.  I zipped through that middle section, possibly playing it even better than I did the first time.  And . . . you guessed it.  Crickets.  File corrupted.  Page not found.  I will not print the word that came into my mind.

This, I knew, was bad.  Really bad.  My attempt at a restart had not solved the problem.  Was I really going to be reduced to the ignominy of an unconditional surrender?  Was I going to sit there for a moment and then waive the white flag by getting up and slinking back to my seat?  I had to do something.

At that point the answer presented itself to me.  If you think I remembered the beginning to the missing part of Drum Boogie, you would be mistaken.  I did, however, remember the two chords that were the ending to the piece.  I played them.  With some authority.  And then I stood up to the loudest applause I have ever experienced in my life.

Having reached (and exceeded) adulthood I now know how excruciating the experience was for every adult in that audience.  While the other kids were surely snickering at the idiot who forgot how to play, every single adult was surely breaking into a sweat, hoping that the poor kid at the keyboard would make it.  He did not, but he kinda sorta recovered.  In a way.

Everyone told me how great I had been and tried to console me about the, er, little problem.  Everyone complimented me on my big finish.  Nobody, of course, told me the truth (that would have been something like “Kid, it almost killed me listening to you flub that thing.  I hoped and hoped that you could recover and was totally relieved when you managed those final notes.  Great save.”)  But all of them being kindhearted adults, they would say no such thing.

There was an upside.  My mother had been clear from the beginning that I would have to take lessons for at least two years.  This was the conclusion to year two.  There would not be a year three.

Somewhere I still have that sheet music to Drum Boogie.  There was a point in time when my own kids were taking lessons and I found my old piano book.  I tried to bring myself back up to the skill level I had exhibited at age eleven.  I got part way there.  But I could not work up the enthusiasm to to attempt Drum Boogie.

Some things should just be left alone.


Image credit: 1957 sheet music cover of Drum Boogie by June Weybright.  Offered for sale on

21 thoughts on “The Piano Recital

  1. Ouch, that’s painful. And blanking out at age 11 is truly terrible. Perhaps your subconscious was toying with you?

    The upside is you ceased taking piano lessons on a high note. Sort of.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Oh yes, that would have been every bit as bad, and maybe worse because of the bigger audience of kids you would have to see every day. Hopefully your dream did not pile on by making your pants fall down too. 😯

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Oh glory, I am so glad I resisted piano lessons. I still get that, when I have to speak in public I totally blank out and do not remember what I said afterwards. People tell me I’m a good speaker and should do it more often, but I am not so sure. Much better that I play rhythm guitar in band, when I flub it there are others to keep going.

    And reading music, I share your lack of proficiency there. I always say when it comes to music I read letters, and my son reads sentances. Talented children can be so annoying 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • At one time I thought that if I could go back to my childhood book with the eyes/brain of an adult the reading would click. Nope. At least not in the amount of time I allotted.


  3. I youtubed Drum Boogie and watched/listened to it a bit. Great tune! Impressive that you pretty well mastered that song.

    As for reading sheet music, the closest I got was in choir class in school. Give me a hymn book now and I just listen, ignoring the notes that are foreign to my eyes, and following the lead of the choir in church. Hopefully they are not signing to slowly so as to lose my interest.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I am sure that my version was likely written for piano students and was thus simplified a lot.

      I later picked up trombone and found it so much easier to read one note at a time rather than the 6 and 8 at a time on a piano. I concluded that one mouth makes for easier playing than ten fingers. 🙂 And I have an opposite problem in church – growing up Lutheran, the hymnals contained the notes for the four parts commonly sung in choirs. The modern Catholic hymnals only use the melody note which is in too high of a range for me much of the time. A bass clef would be so welcome.


  4. That reminds me of another story, my son was going to play a trumpet piece in church on easter when he was about 12. He started, hit a wrong note and stopped. Started again, hit the same wrong note and stopped. We were dying, as I’m sure was every other adult in the packed church.

    Then one of the slides dropped off his trumpet, it had been out of place causing the wrong note. He picked up the piece, put it back on, restarted for the third time and nailed it.

    He was quite unfazed by the whole thing, and we bought him a better horn after that..

    Liked by 1 person

    • The vindication in overcoming a mechanical defect must have been sweet.

      My mother used to tell a story about how during one Christmas program at her church when she was a high school kid, she was given a short solo. As it approached she and her sister had made eye contact and both got a bad case of the giggles. Mom made it through the solo, but not well at all (and my aunt was not a bit of help). She said that their mother was absolutely furious at the both of them. There was no cheap instrument to blame that one on. Now I smile whenever I hear Once In Royal David’s City (which is mighty seldom these days.)


  5. I am so impressed that you had the presence of mind to do a hard reboot and go back to the part you DID remember, J.P. — and to then pull out the big finish when the reboot didn’t work. I had the exact same thing happen, but was way less cool under pressure than you. (I stopped piano lessons shortly afterward, too.) Great post!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks Heidi. As I think about it, it’s kind of a mystery why when I was trying to get rid of my piano why I didn’t roll it into the driveway and chop it into firewood and contraband ivory.

      Welcome to my little club. Your mortifying experience entitles you to life membership. Jim Grey’s dreams only rate guest privileges. 😀

      Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks Annie. I guess it was good to get a freeze like this under my belt at a young age. They are so much worse when there is something real at stake.


  6. I’ve been reading through the archives of your blog over the past week or two and recently searched YouTube for a piano version of Drum Boogie since I’m not familiar with the piece. Would this have been something Gene Krupa would have originally contributed to? If so, I’ve found some great renditions.


      • Sounds like one of those familiar Elementary-school music book-type compositions or arrangements, then. You can bet faking them on piano and marimba and mastering them from drum set sheet music took up a lot of my youth.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s